Here are the results:

Nightmare Chica - 0
Jack-O-Chica - 0
Rockstar Chica - 0
Chica - 0
Withered Chica - 1
Nightmare Mangle - 2
Mangle - 2
Funtime Foxy - 3  
Ennard - 4
Toy Bonnie - 4
The Puppet - 7
Ballora - 35
Funtime Chica - 69
Toy Chica - 72

Wedgie - 6
In Workout Gear - 8
Outercourse - 10
Strip Poker - 11
On a Swing, Butt Hanging - 12
Mouth Nipples - 12
Footjob - 14
Instant Loss
2Koma - 16
With Boobs - 17
Held up and Fucked - 17
Impregnation - 18
Doggy Style - 19
Fuck Machine - 19
Fored Orgasm - 21
Kinky Bullying - 43
Futa - 45

Had some troubles with this one. I'll probably use a different voting system next time.  But thanks to all those who participated!